This Week's ChessBase Show: Stopa-Benjamin, World Open 2009
There is nothing (too) wrong with Philidor's Defense, and its notable advocates include stars like Nisipeanu, Beliavsky, Azmaiparashvili and - at least in the 2009 World Open - Joel Benjamin. It seemed to go pretty well for him, at least until round 7, against Polish IM Jacek Stopa.
Benjamin went for one of the very sharpest lines in the Philidor, a remarkable gambit idea of Romanian GM Liviu-Dieter Nisipeanu, and the players followed the beaten track through move 10. Stopa's 11th move was very rare, having been played just once before. That game was a 2008 contest in which Black achieved a pretty easy draw, but on move 13 Stopa introduced a novelty.
Was it prepared at home or over the board improvisation? My guess is the latter, for reasons that will become clear as we examine the game more closely, but this will serve as a launching pad to discuss the role of computers and human ingenuity in preparation. At this point, at least, computers haven't manage to solve chess, so the question of how the two fit remains a pressing one.
As for the game, Stopa went on to win, quickly, with an attractive concluding combination. Whether he should have won in that way is something we'll discuss during the show. When? It will be at the usual time: Wednesday night at 9 p.m. ET, which is equivalent to 3 a.m. CET early Thursday morning. But whatever time it is where you are, I very much hope to see you there. To watch, log on to the Playchess server at the appropriate time, go to the Broadcast room, and select Stopa-Benjamin from the Games menu. The show runs for about an hour and is free as air.